Answer :

AL2006

-- I believe there's a typo in your question, and
you meant to type ' 41' instead of ' 51 '.

-- Here's how to arrange them:

-----------------------
|  43  |  36  |  41  |
-----------------------
|  38  |  40  |  42  |
-----------------------
|  39  |  44  |  37  |
-----------------------

The diagonals also add up to 120.