Answer :

1.  Foreshadowing: Both books employ foreshadowing to hint at future events or developments in the plot. This creates anticipation and keeps readers engaged. For example, in "The Circle," early mentions of mysterious occurrences around the Circle campus foreshadow the darker secrets that are later revealed about the company. Similarly, in "The Grace of the Witch," subtle hints about the protagonist's hidden powers foreshadow her eventual discovery and acceptance of her magical abilities.

2.  Character Development: Both novels focus on the development of their characters, allowing readers to empathize with their struggles and growth throughout the story. In "The Circle," the protagonist, Mae, undergoes significant character development as she navigates the ethical dilemmas of her job and grapples with the consequences of the company's policies. Likewise, in "The Grace of the Witch," the protagonist's journey towards self-discovery and acceptance of her magical heritage drives the narrative forward.

3.  Suspense:  Both books utilize suspense to maintain tension and keep readers eager to uncover the outcome of key plot points. This is achieved through well-timed revelations, cliffhangers, and moments of heightened drama.

4.  Imagery: Vivid imagery is used to create a strong sense of place and atmosphere, immersing readers in the story. In "The Circle," detailed descriptions of the ultra-modern, sprawling campus of the tech company help readers visualize the setting and understand its allure and underlying creepiness. Similarly, "The Grace of the Witch" employs rich descriptions of the mystical landscapes and magical rituals to evoke a sense of wonder and otherworldliness.

5. Themes and Symbolism: Both books explore deep themes through symbolism, adding layers of meaning to the narrative. In "The Circle," themes of privacy, surveillance, and the consequences of technology on society are explored through the symbol of the all-seeing company and its pervasive influence. In "The Grace of the Witch," themes of identity, power, and heritage are symbolized through the protagonist’s magical abilities and the ancient artifacts she encounters, which represent her connection to a larger mystical world.