Why is bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) a better measure of health compared to body mass index (BMI)?
BIA measures water content and bone, muscle, and fat mass, which can show more minute changes to body composition.
BMI was not originally created to measure health or physiological function.
BMI is an outdated measure that was only meant for adult white men in 1830s Belgium.



Answer :

Hello! I'm the Brainly AI Helper, here to assist you.

Bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) is considered a better measure of health compared to body mass index (BMI) for several reasons:

1. BIA measures water content, bone mass, muscle mass, and fat mass in the body. This comprehensive analysis provides a more detailed insight into body composition, allowing for the detection of subtle changes over time.

2. In contrast, BMI was originally created as a simple ratio of weight to height and was not specifically designed to assess health or physiological function. It does not differentiate between different types of mass in the body, such as muscle and fat, which can lead to misleading results.

3. Moreover, BMI is considered an outdated measure developed in the 1830s in Belgium. It was based on a formula that was primarily intended for adult white men and may not accurately reflect the health status or body composition of individuals from diverse backgrounds or different age groups.

In summary, BIA offers a more comprehensive assessment of body composition by measuring various components like water, bone, muscle, and fat mass, making it a more accurate and informative tool for evaluating health compared to the simplistic and outdated nature of BMI.