Planets A and B have the same mass, but Planet A is half the size of Planet B. Which statement correctly explains the weight you would experience on each planet?

A. You would weigh the same on both planets because your mass would be the same on both.
B. You would weigh less on Planet A because the distance between you and the planet's center of gravity would be smaller.
C. You would weigh the same on both planets because the masses of the planets are the same.
D. You would weigh more on Planet A because the distance between you and the planet's center of gravity would be smaller.



Answer :

Let's analyze the given problem step-by-step.

1. Given Information:
- Planets A and B have the same mass.
- Planet A is half the size of planet B.

2. Key Concepts:
- Weight on a planet depends on the gravitational force exerted by the planet.
- Gravitational force [tex]\((F)\)[/tex] is given by Newton's law of universal gravitation:
[tex]\[ F = \frac{G \cdot m_1 \cdot m_2}{r^2} \][/tex]
where [tex]\(G\)[/tex] is the gravitational constant, [tex]\(m_1\)[/tex] and [tex]\(m_2\)[/tex] are the masses of the two objects (e.g., a person and the planet), and [tex]\(r\)[/tex] is the distance between the centers of the two masses (the radius of the planet if we consider the person on the surface).
- If two planets have the same mass but different sizes, the gravitational force (and thereby the weight experienced) will depend on the radius of the planets.

3. Analysis of Each Statement:
- Statement A: "You would weigh the same on both planets because your mass would be the same on both."
- This is incorrect. Your weight depends on the gravitational force, not just your mass. The force also involves the radius of the planet.

- Statement B: "You would weigh less on planet A because the distance between you and the planet's center of gravity would be smaller."
- This is incorrect. A smaller distance (smaller radius) would actually result in a stronger gravitational force and hence a greater weight.

- Statement C: "You would weigh the same on both planets because the masses of the planets are the same."
- This is incorrect. Even though the masses of the planets are the same, the gravitational force also depends on the radius of the planet, which is different.

- Statement D: "You would weigh more on planet A because the distance between you and the planet's center of gravity would be smaller."
- This is correct. Since planet A is half the size of planet B, the radius (r) is smaller for planet A. A smaller radius increases the gravitational force due to the inverse-square law [tex]\(\left( \frac{1}{r^2} \right)\)[/tex]. Thus, you would weigh more on planet A.

4. Conclusion:
- The correct statement is D: "You would weigh more on planet A because the distance between you and the planet's center of gravity would be smaller."

Therefore, the correct answer is D.