Answered

Select the correct answer.

A team of scientists placed five rocks in five separate, artificial environments. All the rocks came from the same formation and had the same chemical composition. The table describes the environment for each rock:

\begin{tabular}{|c|c|c|c|c|}
\hline
Rock A & Rock B & Rock C & Rock D & Rock E \\
\hline
\begin{tabular}{l}
- intermittent rain showers \\
- temperatures alternating between \\
[tex]$-2^{\circ} C$[/tex] and [tex]$20^{\circ} C$[/tex]
\end{tabular}
&
\begin{tabular}{l}
- frequent acidic showers containing \\
carbonic acid
\end{tabular}
&
\begin{tabular}{l}
- covered with algae and lichen
\end{tabular}
&
\begin{tabular}{l}
- placed in an oxygen-rich environment
\end{tabular}
&
\begin{tabular}{l}
- hot and dry environment \\
- low temperature of [tex]$35^{\circ} C$[/tex]
\end{tabular} \\
\hline
\end{tabular}

After the experiment, the scientists observed that one particular rock had large fractures and had split into two pieces. They also observed that, compared to the other rocks, the chemical composition of this particular rock had remained largely unchanged. Which rock most likely fits this description?

A. Rock A
B. Rock B
C. Rock C
D. Rock D
E. Rock E



Answer :

Let's analyze the given environments for each rock to determine which one is most likely to develop large fractures and remain chemically unchanged:

1. Rock A:
- Intermittent rain showers.
- Temperatures alternating between -2°C and 20°C.

2. Rock B:
- Frequent acidic showers that contain carbonic acid.

3. Rock C:
- Covered with algae and lichen.

4. Rock D:
- Placed in an oxygen-rich environment.

5. Rock E:
- Hot and dry environment.
- Low temperature of 35°C.

### Analyzing the Factors:

1. Rock A:
- Intermittent rain showers: Rain can lead to physical weathering due to wetting and drying cycles.
- Temperature alternating between -2°C and 20°C: This range includes freeze-thaw cycles. Water can seep into cracks and freeze, expanding and causing the rock to fracture.

2. Rock B:
- Frequent acidic showers: This would lead to chemical weathering rather than physical fracturing.

3. Rock C:
- Covered with algae and lichen: This environment promotes biological weathering, which can alter the chemical composition over time.

4. Rock D:
- Oxygen-rich environment: This can lead to oxidation-related chemical weathering, affecting the chemical composition.

5. Rock E:
- Hot and dry environment with a low temperature of 35°C: This environment is likely to cause thermal expansion and contraction, but less likely to result in significant fractures compared to freeze-thaw cycles. Also, it might alter the chemical composition if any chemical reactions occur at high temperatures.

### Conclusion:

Given the environment descriptions and their effects:
- Rock A experiences significant physical stress from freeze-thaw cycles, causing large fractures.
- Rock A remains largely chemically unchanged since the primary weathering process here is physical rather than chemical.

Thus, the rock that most likely fits the description of having large fractures and remaining chemically unchanged is Rock A.

Answer: A. Rock A