Cara computes the mean and variance for the set [tex]$87, 46, 90, 78,$ and 89[/tex]. She finds the mean to be 78. Her steps for finding the variance are shown below.

[tex]\[
\begin{array}{l}
\sigma^2=\frac{(87-78)^2+(46-78)^2+(90-78)^2+(78-78)^2+(89-78)^2}{5} \\
\sigma^2=\frac{(9)^2-(32)^2+(12)^2+0^2+(11)^2}{5} \\
\sigma^2=\frac{81-1024+144+0+121}{5} \\
\sigma^2=\frac{-678}{5}=-135.6
\end{array}
\][/tex]

What is the first error Cara made in computing the variance?



Answer :

Let's go through the correct steps to compute the variance to identify where Cara made her first error.

1. Compute the Mean: Cara correctly calculated the mean to be 78.

2. Calculate the Squared Differences from the Mean:
- [tex]\((87 - 78)^2 = 81\)[/tex]
- [tex]\((46 - 78)^2 = 1024\)[/tex]
- [tex]\((90 - 78)^2 = 144\)[/tex]
- [tex]\((78 - 78)^2 = 0\)[/tex]
- [tex]\((89 - 78)^2 = 121\)[/tex]

So, the squared differences from the mean are [tex]\([81, 1024, 144, 0, 121]\)[/tex].

3. Sum of Squared Differences:
[tex]\[ 81 + 1024 + 144 + 0 + 121 = 1370 \][/tex]

4. Compute the Variance (using the population formula):
[tex]\[ \sigma^2 = \frac{1370}{5} = 274.0 \][/tex]

However, let's follow Cara's method to identify where she went wrong.

Cara's work:
[tex]\[ \sigma^2=\frac{(87-78)^2 + (46-78)^2 + (90-78)^2 + (78-78)^2 + (89-78)^2}{5} \][/tex]
[tex]\[ \sigma^2=\frac{(9)^2 - (32)^2 + (12)^2 + 0^2 + (11)^2}{5} \][/tex]

Notice that instead of correctly calculating each squared difference individually, she made an error:

- Correct calculation:
[tex]\[ (9)^2 = 81 \][/tex]
[tex]\[ (32)^2 = 1024 \quad \text{(Should have been added, not subtracted)} \][/tex]
[tex]\[ (12)^2 = 144 \][/tex]
[tex]\[ 0^2 = 0 \][/tex]
[tex]\[ (11)^2 = 121 \][/tex]

Cara calculated:
[tex]\[ \sigma^2=\frac{81 - 1024 + 144 + 0 + 121}{5} \][/tex]

She incorrectly subtracted [tex]\((32)^2 = 1024\)[/tex] instead of adding it.

Cara's Step:
[tex]\[ \sigma^2=\frac{81 - 1024 + 144 + 0 + 121}{5} = \frac{-678}{5} = -135.6 \][/tex]

### Conclusion:
The first error Cara made was in the subtraction of [tex]\((46 - 78)^2\)[/tex], which should have been added instead. This is the reason why her calculation for the sum of squared differences resulted in an incorrect negative number.

Other Questions