Short Writing Prompt

Review the debate between former presidents Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan. Determine which candidate, in your opinion, proposed a more compelling argument about lowering inflation.

In a short writing of 4-5 sentences, evaluate which candidate proposed a more compelling argument. Finish the evaluation with a statement on how the candidate's claim could have been made stronger.

Support your evaluation with specific data presented by each of the candidates. Mention the candidate's claim, their reasoning, and evidence to support the reasoning. Also, provide one counterpoint by the opponent and the evidence used to refute the counterpoint.



Answer :

Final answer:

Ronald Reagan proposed a compelling argument on lowering inflation by highlighting Carter's economic challenges and questioning voters' well-being. Carter focused on long-term stability and the effects of his measures on inflation, but could have provided more detailed plans to address the issue.


Explanation:

Ronald Reagan presented a compelling argument about lowering inflation during the 1980 election. Reagan highlighted the high interest rates under Carter's administration, linking them to inflation and economic challenges. He asked voters, 'Are you better off than you were four years ago?' to emphasize the negative impact of inflation on their lives. However, Reagan's claim could have been made stronger by providing more detailed plans for addressing inflation beyond critiquing Carter's approach.

On the other hand, Jimmy Carter argued that his actions would reduce inflation over time and blamed the recession on broader economic issues. Carter's reasoning included the understanding that halting inflationary measures was necessary for long-term economic stability. A stronger claim from Carter could have involved more specific policies to combat inflation and a clearer explanation of how his measures would lead to economic recovery.

A counterpoint to Reagan's argument could have been that while high interest rates were a challenge, they were a result of combating inflation, which was a necessary step. This counterpoint could be supported by economic data showing the correlation between interest rates and inflation.


Learn more about Presidential candidates' arguments on lowering inflation here:

https://brainly.com/question/33937875