Study the question and statements given below. Decide whether any information provided in the statements is redundant and/or can be dispensed with to answer it.

If 7 is added to the numerator and denominator of the fraction [tex]\frac{a}{b}[/tex], will the new fraction be less than the original one? (Assume both [tex]a[/tex] and [tex]b[/tex] to be positive).

Statement I: [tex]a = 73, b = 103[/tex]
Statement II: The average of [tex]a[/tex] and [tex]b[/tex] is less than [tex]b[/tex].
Statement III: [tex]a - 5[/tex] is greater than [tex]b - 5[/tex].

a. II and either I or III
b. Only I or III
c. Any two of them
d. Any one of them



Answer :

Let's analyze the problem and each of the statements provided.

The problem is: Will the new fraction [tex]\((a + 7) / (b + 7)\)[/tex] be less than the original fraction [tex]\(a / b\)[/tex]?

To solve this, we should consider the statements given:

### Statement-I: [tex]\(a = 73, b = 103\)[/tex]

Given this statement, we can directly plug in these values into our fractions:
- Original fraction: [tex]\(\frac{73}{103}\)[/tex]
- New fraction: [tex]\(\frac{73 + 7}{103 + 7} = \frac{80}{110}\)[/tex]

We can compare these fractions directly, which shows:

- [tex]\(\frac{73}{103} \approx 0.7087\)[/tex]
- [tex]\(\frac{80}{110} \approx 0.7273\)[/tex]

Since [tex]\(0.7273\)[/tex] is not less than [tex]\(0.7087\)[/tex], the new fraction is not less than the original fraction.

### Statement-II: The average of [tex]\(a\)[/tex] and [tex]\(b\)[/tex] is less than [tex]\(b\)[/tex].

The average of [tex]\(a\)[/tex] and [tex]\(b\)[/tex] is [tex]\(\frac{a + b}{2}\)[/tex].
If the average is less than [tex]\(b\)[/tex], this means:
[tex]\[ \frac{a + b}{2} < b \implies a + b < 2b \implies a < b \][/tex]

This information tells us that [tex]\(a\)[/tex] is less than [tex]\(b\)[/tex], but does not provide specific values, so we cannot directly compare the fractions without knowing the exact values of [tex]\(a\)[/tex] and [tex]\(b\)[/tex].

### Statement-III: [tex]\(a - 5\)[/tex] is greater than [tex]\(b - 5\)[/tex].

This implies that [tex]\(a > b\)[/tex], but this is inconsistent with Statement-II where [tex]\(a < b\)[/tex]. Therefore, one of these statements is incorrect or redundant.

Given Statement-II ([tex]\(a < b\)[/tex]) and noting that [tex]\(a = 73\)[/tex] and [tex]\(b = 103\)[/tex] indeed satisfies [tex]\(a < b\)[/tex], we can discard Statement-III since it conflicts with the known facts (as per Statement-I).

### Decision on Redundancy:
With Statement-I alone, we were able to determine the comparison between the original and the new fraction. Therefore, the other statements are redundant for answering the question.

### Conclusion:
Option b. "Only I or III" is the correct answer since only Statement-I is needed to determine whether the new fraction is less than the original one, and Statement-III is incorrect and therefore redundant.