Charlie is investigating friction. She will use the same amount of force to push two wooden balls across two level surfaces. Then she will record her results in the table below.

\begin{tabular}{|l|l|l|l|l|}
\hline
Trial & Ball & Weight & Surface & Distance Ball Moved \\
\hline
1 & [tex]$X$[/tex] & 1 lb & polished tile & \\
\hline
2 & [tex]$X$[/tex] & 1 lb & pavement & \\
\hline
3 & [tex]$Y$[/tex] & 2 lb & polished tile & \\
\hline
4 & [tex]$Y$[/tex] & 2 lb & pavement & \\
\hline
\end{tabular}

Which prediction will most likely describe how friction will affect her findings?

A. The distance for Trial 3 will be greater than the distance for Trial 1 partly because the weight difference of the balls will affect friction.

B. The distance for Trial 2 will be greater than the distance for Trial 1 because the difference in surface roughness will affect friction.

C. The distance for Trial 4 will be greater than the distance for Trial 2 partly because the weight difference of the balls will affect friction.

D. The distance for Trial 3 will be greater than the distance for Trial 4 because the difference in surface roughness will affect friction.



Answer :

To answer this question, we must consider how weight and surface roughness affect friction, which in turn affects the distance the balls will move.

1. Trial Analysis:
- Trial 1: Ball [tex]\(X\)[/tex] (1 lb) on polished tile.
- Trial 2: Ball [tex]\(X\)[/tex] (1 lb) on pavement.
- Trial 3: Ball [tex]\(Y\)[/tex] (2 lb) on polished tile.
- Trial 4: Ball [tex]\(Y\)[/tex] (2 lb) on pavement.

2. Friction Considerations:
- Polished tile is a smoother surface compared to pavement, hence it has less friction.
- Pavement is rougher, thus it has more friction.
- Heavier objects experience greater friction due to the increased normal force.

Let's evaluate each prediction statement:

1. The distance for Trial 3 will be greater than the distance for Trial 1 partly because the weight difference of the balls will affect friction.
- Both trials are on the polished tile. Trial 3 has a heavier ball.
- Heavier objects experience more friction, so the distance in Trial 3 (2 lb) would actually be less, not more, than in Trial 1 (1 lb).
- This statement is incorrect.

2. The distance for Trial 2 will be greater than the distance for Trial 1 because the difference in surface roughness will affect friction.
- Trial 2 is on pavement; Trial 1 is on polished tile.
- Pavement has more friction than polished tile. Hence, the distance on pavement (Trial 2) should be less than on a polished tile (Trial 1).
- This statement is incorrect.

3. The distance for Trial 4 will be greater than the distance for Trial 2 partly because the weight difference of the balls will affect friction.
- Both trials are on pavement, but Trial 4 has a heavier ball.
- Heavier objects experience more friction, so the distance in Trial 4 (2 lb) would be less than in Trial 2 (1 lb).
- This statement is incorrect.

4. The distance for Trial 3 will be greater than the distance for Trial 4 because the difference in surface roughness will affect friction.
- Trial 3 is on polished tile; Trial 4 is on pavement, and both use the same ball [tex]\(Y\)[/tex] (2 lb).
- Polished tile has less friction than pavement, so the distance on polished tile (Trial 3) will be greater than on pavement (Trial 4).
- This statement is correct.

Therefore, the most likely prediction is:

The distance for Trial 3 will be greater than the distance for Trial 4 because the difference in surface roughness will affect friction.

This aligns with statement 4 as the correct answer.